The TSA Has Determined That My Cheese Is Not Explosive
November 30, 2007 on 4:44 am | In Miscellaneous, Travel | 10 Comments
Before leaving San Francisco for home in Cambridge, I stopped at the Ferry Building on the Embarcadero to pick up a few gifts for home. Among them was a small muffin-sized package of delicious, creamy Mount Tam cheese from Cowgirl Creamery in Point Reyes, CA, a favorite of my wife’s. I stashed it in my shoulder bag before catching the BART train to the airport.
Arriving at SFO I pleasantly breezed through the metal detector on my way to the gate and waited for my bag and laptop to come through the X-ray machine. The pleasant breezing sensation then came to an abrupt halt, as did the X-ray conveyor belt. My bag went back and forth through the machine several times.
“Can I please open your bag, sir?” a TSA contractor asked me. Her shoulder insignia read “Centurion Security Services, S.A.F.E.S.K.I.E.S.” emblazoned on a ferocious eagle-and-flag backdrop. I wondered what on earth the super-sized acronym could possibly stand for.
“No problem.” I’m not inclined to be overly protective of my bags’ privacy in these sad police-state times we live in. I assumed that the shape or size of something in my bag reminded someone of a sample X-ray they dimly remembered from the TSA X-ray Analysis training seminar. I didn’t want my behavior to remind someone of something they saw in some other TSA seminar, such as that fascinating Strip-Search Profiling Criteria class they took. I put my shoes back on and waited while, after several rummages, the cheese emerged. Much examination and discussion took place as the cheese was passed around and looked at from many angles. It received several prods and squeezes.
“We’ll run your bag through again, sir.”
“No problem,” I said. I was thinking, “Good, they’ve determined it’s merely a cheese, and once my bag scans OK, I’m out of here.”
The bag went back, came through again. But my cheese was not freed. Without further consultation with me, my TSA handler escorted my cheese to a holding area where several other TSA types were lurking. (I wanted to write, “She frogmarched my cheese to a holding area,” because it sounds so much better, but two people are required to frogmarch a cheese and there was only one of her.) There was much more discussion and cheese-prodding. My handler came back sans fromage, as they say at French security checkpoints.
“Sir, how much does your cheese weigh?”
“I don’t know.”
“There is a rule that you cannot bring liquids or gels over three ounces past the TSA checkpoint.”
“I know that, but this cheese is not a gel. It is just a soft cheese.” Inwardly I wondered if cheese was in fact a gel, technically speaking. It didn’t really matter, though. These people were not about to engage in arguments about whether cheese was a gel, a sol, a colloidal emulsion, or any other hair-splitting nonsense employed by classic strip-search candidates.
“It’s the consistency, sir. It is creamy. It is a creamy cheese. Also, there is no weight on the label.” (I breathed a sigh of relief and silently thanked Cowgirl Creamery’s label designer for this lapse of specificity.) “We’re going to have to weigh it.”
The action shifted back to the bevy of cheese-handlers. They seemed indecisive. No scale appeared to be handy as they passed the cheese among themselves, looking concerned and non-plussed. I was gearing up and considering my options. I was just deciding that it would be an appropriate bureaucratic revenge to assert my right to take home exactly three ounces of cheese when the group apparently gave up. My handler returned, cheese in hand.
“Sir, please come over here with me.” We went over to one of those explosive-analysis units. I unconsciously put my bag down on its metal surface. “NO!!! DO NOT put that bag there, sir!” I removed it, but I was relieved. I could feel a lecture coming on, which meant that the cheese might soon be free after being duly reprimanded for its creaminess.
She pointed to the TSA rules posted on the unit. “Sir, our rules clearly state that passengers may only take three ounces or less of gels or liquids in a clear transparent bag. This cheese is a gel consistency, but you do not have a transparent bag.”
“It’s true that I don’t have a bag. But, ma’am, I think you can understand why I might not have realized that cheese would be considered a gel by the TSA.”
“If you had checked the TSA website, you would have known that you needed a bag.” I did not argue about whether I could have checked the TSA website. My cheese was now in one of those WW II POW escape movies. It had escaped the cellblock via a clever plot, but still had to don the stolen SS uniform and make it past the guards at the perimeter fence. “Here is a bag,” said my handler. She produced a small Ziploc, placed the cheese inside, sealed it tightly, but did not return it yet. There was a long, pregnant pause as the searchlights swept the ground, looking for escapees. “When you go through the checkpoint, this is the kind of bag you must place it in.”
“Yes, ma’am. I will do that in the future.” She gave me the cheese and, reunited, the cheese and I left for Gate A6. It’s been kind of a bonding experience, to the tell the truth. I may hold onto that Mount Tam as a souvenir, at least until the smell becomes a bit strong. Or until my wife eats it. Whichever is sooner.
10 Comments »
RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI
Leave a comment
Entries and comments feeds.
Valid XHTML and CSS.
All content copyright (c) 2006-2007 Joseph Berkovitz. All Rights Reserved.
that’s hilarious! i brought the same exact cheese back on a flight in july 2005 with no problem (contained only in a cowgirl creamery fabric lunchbag). maybe the fact that i had two other, firmer cheeses in the bag disguised it by association.
Comment by kathryn — November 30, 2007 #
and yet, oddly enough, the only relevant reference to cheese on the TSA’s web site is to cheese in a pressurized can here:
http://www.tsa.gov/travelers/airtravel/prohibited/permitted-prohibited-items.shtm
Comment by John O'Keefe — November 30, 2007 #
Great story, Joe – one which I am forwarding to all of my traveling friends, whether they eat cheese or not! I hope by now that lovely Max soon devours a cheese that went through such work to get to her. (I wonder – does cheese get sharper if exposed to stress?)
Someday there will be the cheese equivalent of Richard Reid, the shoe bomber. Somebody will be on board an international flight and attempt to light a fuse in a wedge of brie and fromage will be banned forever.
Steve
Comment by Steve Alburty — November 30, 2007 #
The cheese stands alone… at a security checkpoint, waiting to be deemed unblowupable (a word that is thrown around a lot, these days). :)
Comment by Annalisa Oswald — December 2, 2007 #
Reminds me of Ben Forta’s experience a few months ago:
Peanut-Butter is a gel?
http://www.forta.com/blog/index.cfm/2007/10/31/TSA-Peanut-Butter-Is-A-Gel
Comment by Oscar — December 5, 2007 #
Hilarious!
You will probably be permitted to travel with a talcum powder container full of gun powder or a large water bra full of nitro, but traveling with a small wheel of soft cheese will get you stopped at security checkpoints.
Also, according to the TSA website, you are permitted to travel with pointed scissors, screwdrivers, safety razors and corkscrews; however, they are very suspicious about cheese.
And, last but certainly not least, snow globes of any kind are strictly forbidden. I am not making that up, check the TSA site for yourself.
http://www.tsa.gov/travelers/airtravel/prohibited/permitted-prohibited-items.shtm
Comment by Jon Doe — December 5, 2007 #
I love the comments, and I especially love the contents of the TSA website which I had never browsed before.
“Cheese in pressurized containers” is allowed for under 3 oz., as John O’Keefe pointed out. But I fail to see how any statements made by anyone about this, er, substance could be interpreted as applying to actual cheese.
Comment by joe — December 5, 2007 #
Haha… Wondering… If the cheese gets too sharp, while waiting, will it be treated as a knife?
Comment by John — February 1, 2008 #
Ah – Cowgirl Cheese at SFO…..my story has to do with Air France. (Somehow the Cowgirl Creamery insulated bag full of fresh West Marin cheese made it past TSA – whose acronym refers to the Thousands Standing Around while airport “security” dithers and dawdles.) The Air France stewardesses graciously placed my cheeses in their refrigerator for the flight to Paris, where my friends LOVED our delicious Cowgirl Creamery cheeses! I’m glad that yours made it through, too – a great tale.
Comment by Marc Matheson — November 16, 2009 #
Alas, the French security in Lyon was not as understanding when I attempted to bring some firm goat cheese to the UK. I had my liquids in the required plastic bag but the cheese was in an insulated bag in my carry-on. I had no idea that cheese was a prohibited item – it does not appear on the sign listing prohibited items but it is on the airport website (after clicking on several links to find the appropriate .pdf file). 20 euros of cheese in the trash (snif!)
Comment by David Bruce — December 28, 2009 #